Dog Societies, Cats, and Why Checks Matter More Than Ideology

Written by

on

You have a society of obedient dogs listening to their masters. What do non-divinely-guided human masters typically do when they’re in an unchallenged position of power? They exploit. What do they do when their power is challenged? They restrict their underlings and reduce their freedom.

Left unchecked, a dog society regresses. Not always, not on a fixed timeline, but reliably enough that it’s worth naming as a pattern: Islamic empires and states across history, Nazi Germany, and — more recently and on a much smaller scale — the institutional moves of Trump’s second term.

The fix isn’t ideology. It’s cats: people in or near power who speak their minds, oppose, and refuse to fall in line. A society with functioning cats resists the slide. A society that has them removed, defanged, or never had them to begin with, doesn’t.

What a “cat” actually is

To make this more than a slogan, a cat needs to be something you can point to before you know the outcome, not something you infer backward from “well, that country didn’t collapse, so it must have had one.” Concretely: a free press that can report on power without being shut down, an independent judiciary that can rule against the executive and have that ruling matter, an opposition that can contest power without being jailed or disqualified, and institutional watchdogs with the standing to investigate their own government. Where these exist and function, the exploitation reflex gets caught early. Where they’re absent or hollowed out, it doesn’t.

Where this actually shows up, specifically

Early Islamic civilization, particularly in its so-called Golden Age, had meaningfully more intellectual and legal pluralism than what came after — real debate, competing schools of jurisprudence, room for dissent. That openness narrowed over centuries in most of the region. It’s not a claim that “Islamic countries” are one continuous subject — the Abbasid Caliphate, the Ottoman Empire, and modern Saudi Arabia aren’t the same polity — it’s a claim that the pattern (less internal challenge to power over time, more restriction) shows up repeatedly across very different Islamic-majority states and eras.

Nazi Germany is the cleanest case, because the removal of cats is dated and documented: the independent press, courts, and opposition parties were dismantled within about a year of the Nazis taking power, 1933–34. That’s not a vague vibe, it’s a specific institutional demolition you can point to.

Trump’s second term is the newest and smallest-scale case, but it’s not just a talking point — there’s a real, sustained, cross-institutional pattern through 2025:

  • Within hours of taking office, four career civil servants running the immigration courts (the chief immigration judge, the acting EOIR director, its general counsel, and its head of policy) were fired without warning.
  • Within the first week, roughly 17 inspectors general — the internal watchdogs across federal agencies — were fired in a late-night mass dismissal. A federal judge later found the manner of the firings violated the law.
  • Through the rest of the year, immigration judges kept being removed — 32 in February, 8 more in April, nearly 100 by year’s end — with EOIR leadership explicitly pushing for faster deportation rulings and fewer hearings.
  • In March, FTC Commissioner Rebecca Slaughter was removed; the case went to the Supreme Court, which ruled in the administration’s favor, holding that Congress can’t force the president to keep officials “with whom he cannot work.”

That’s a real pattern: a full year of removing internal oversight and adjudicative officials across multiple institutions, not a one-off. It’s fair to call it evidence of the same dog-society mechanic in miniature.

The actual claim

Strip away the theology and the ideology-shaped headlines, and what’s left is a fairly ordinary and well-supported institutional claim: power without live, reachable checks trends toward exploitation and restriction, regardless of what banner it operates under. The cats matter more than the culture. Islamic countries, Nazi Germany, and the current U.S. administration aren’t the same kind of case or the same scale of case — but they’re instances of the same mechanism, and naming the mechanism precisely is what makes the comparison hold up instead of just being three things I don’t like grouped under one label.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *